diff --git a/commands/games/mafia.js b/commands/games/mafia.js
index 892ad060..deb591ad 100644
--- a/commands/games/mafia.js
+++ b/commands/games/mafia.js
@@ -51,7 +51,7 @@ module.exports = class MafiaCommand extends Command {
 						await player.user.send('Sorry, time is up!');
 						continue;
 					}
-					const choice = valid[Number.parseInt(decision.first().content, 10)].id;
+					const choice = valid[Number.parseInt(decision.first().content, 10) - 1].id;
 					if (player.role === 'mafia') {
 						const chosen = players.get(choice);
 						killed = chosen.id;
diff --git a/commands/games/wizard-convention.js b/commands/games/wizard-convention.js
index 5b09b1d9..40fcd1dd 100644
--- a/commands/games/wizard-convention.js
+++ b/commands/games/wizard-convention.js
@@ -51,7 +51,7 @@ module.exports = class WizardConventionCommand extends Command {
 						await player.user.send('Sorry, time is up!');
 						continue;
 					}
-					const choice = valid[Number.parseInt(decision.first().content, 10)].id;
+					const choice = valid[Number.parseInt(decision.first().content, 10) - 1].id;
 					if (player.role === 'dragon') {
 						const chosen = players.get(choice);
 						eaten = chosen.id;